
Originally Posted by
PeeBee
Andy I have 3 swags, and none of them are perfect. The latest unit I have is the 1100mm wide Darche swag with the 1000mm wide Darche stretcher.
I use this as my go to the others as back up or for friends without swags.
The Darche quality is fine, has a plastic tub base and has never leaked or fallen down, has been in heat and snow up to 6" deep without issue. The matress is good integrity and can be exchanges with a therma rest or supplemented. It has the full length flyscreen shell and is fine to sleep in when 45 deg or minus 10. The combo of widths was recommended to my by a mate and there is a problem with rain running off the swag and wicking/finding its way between the borttom external surface of the plastic tub and the stretcher top surface. In the snow this turns to ice and its cold to sleep on, regardless of the insulation adoption. It also accumulates un heavy rain. The only solution is to rig a tarp over the setup and stop the water reaching the swag. The stretcher is sturdy and well built, and other makes have copied , or maybe Darche copied from them, but its robust, and bit of a handful to fold up though. The stretcher bags is of a good size, but you will never get the swag back into a Darche over bag - so I bought one of those big waterproof roll top style bags and its a perfect combo, slips inside easily and ca be stored on the roof without water and insect/stick damage to the sway floor.
My concern with the Tent World unit is it seems like an integrated design - what happens if the stretcher gets damaged - can the swag be seperated - what if the package is too big - these are usually vacuum packed for transport to sale. The monster size one Winnie suggested looks like an improvement on the Darche - more room for internal dressing. thrashing around and storage, better ventilation I am guessing - the Darche has vents at both head and g=feet - I think this is really important as when its pissing down the ventilation still happens.
Lastly remember its going to be a cotton polyester mix fabric and it will sweat in either hot or cold so ventilation during the day and at home after the trip is essential. Also I found the mattress can get quite wet just from condensation and body contact, so each day you need to pull the mattress out with the sleeping bag and air it out - the polyester mix does not breath. The first swag I have I purchased the 100% canvas from Bedggood and Sons in Ringwood and made my own -it does not sweat, but its very heavy and oppressive in summer heat.
I dont think there is anything wrong with the Darche brand, however there are probably variants out there that are more cost effective but ultimately today they are just all similar.