Thanks to NP99 (who I have now confused with Roofy several times because of the same avatar) for bringing this thread to the top. An emergency beacon is definitely on our 'to get' list. lorrieandjas' post raises several questions for me which I am hopeful might be answered.
I had intended to get a PLB, but the double transmitting time of the epirbs sounds potentially attractive at the cost of a slightly bigger beacon to carry. Are the epirbs very much bigger? We would want to use it whilst walking as well as driving. In reality is the extra 24 hours transmission time likely to make any difference for land based use. I would hope if we ever had need to use it, that we we would be found within a day, or at least our position ascertained.
Regarding the need to change beacons every 3 years. The following is from the GME website (Other manufactures may differ).
GME Emergency Beacons employ some of the latest materials and technologies making a 12 year useful life* achievable in the case of a correctly maintained beacon.
In fulfilling a duty of care to its customers, products that are over 12 years old will not be serviced by GME or any of it's agents.
GME emergency beacons are required to be serviced at intervals not exceeding 6 years for EPIRBs and 7 years for PLBs, products that are not serviced within this period may not perform to specification when needed.
I note the advice that an emergency beacon is no replacement for an HF radio or satellite phone, but HF radio is an enthusiasts tool which requires skills, which may never be utilised, to be learned & remembered (isn't it?). Satellite phone is easier but is expensive. I'm wondering if anyone has had any experience with the SPOT system (
http://www.findmespot.com/en/index.php?cid=102) & whether it offers a cost effective alternative to carrying an emergency beacon AND another means of communication? Would anyone recommend carrying a SPOT thingy only?
Cuppa