Because that is not my call, Personally I would remove the 25 post rule but only have it available to paying forum members
Yes the manuals do bring a lot of traffic 2 the forum but what does this traffic really do for you / the forum?
I don't believe "we snagged a lot of members and good friends as a result of it" I think those like me stayed because of the friendly ( 99% of the time ) community we have here. And yes I did find the forum by doing a google search on GQ manuals, but that has nothing to do with me staying. If you took a poll on who came for the manuals and stayed and done a search between 0 post and 25 posts. I would put money on more people grabbed the manuals and haven't been back and that's even taking into account 50% 0 post for spammers.